Thursday, March 4, 2021

Core Response #3 - Alexandria

I really appreciated the Raphael article, because much like the Gray article from last week, it highlighted how economic imperatives and constraints work to structure and inform the subject matter of television. 


I initially expected this week’s readings to be focused on the emergence of micro-celebrity and influencer culture through reality tv, but I was surprised to find really helpful theorizations of citizenship in relation to media formations and participation. According to McCarthy, reality tv is aligned with neoliberal discourses of resilience as individual in response to systemic injury. Oulette and Hay argued that voting in reality tv aligns consumer participation with political participation in terms of citizen-making. It’s really rough to see how their argument was so prescient, considering the progression of American politics over the past decade. Donald Trump is so central to this argument and perhaps the best example of this cultural process at play. Oulette writes,”While The Apprentice is not overtly about a "political process" (that is, in the narrow sense of "electoral politics"), its demonstrations of corporate accountability become, technically, interdependent with the procedures for political accountability in the United States in these times. This is not to say only that citizens are or that state government operates, like a corporation; it is to say that The Apprentice is one site (and a popular one) where public and private government intersect.” This obviously became a central part of Trump’s rhetoric and political strategy, promising to treat running the country from a “business” mindset—which, to him, represented a stark departure from stagnating, bureaucratic political processes. What occurred with Trump also can be contextualized within a long lineage of tv’s influence on the political sphere and office of the presidency that can be traced to JFK, whose appearances on TV were central to crafting his public persona and the parasocial relationships he developed with American citizens. This idea of tv functioning for the purpose of citizen-making relates to prior readings about earlier periods of tv, like the George Lipsitz reading. But reality tv (with its participatory frameworks and setting in everyday contexts outside of a studio environment) further spreads democracy “out over daily life” (214).

Supplemental Post #2- Rojeen

 During this week's readings, specifically Anna McCarthy's "Reality Television: A Theater of Neoliberal Suffering," I wondered how the reality shows I am currently watching could apply to her argument. As an avid watcher of Master Chef, I notice how Gordon Ramsey and the fellow judges not only severely critique the contestants (often to tears), but how they also offer specific contestants financial or professional help after they are voted off the show. This "undercover philanthropy" is almost always offered to contestants who vocalize their financial instability, or unemployment status (after being probed on camera as to why winning the $250k and show is so important to them), in which they are rewarded with either a job at one of the judges' restaurants or financial help for their families. McCarthy writes how reality shows like Random define their philanthropy as "'people helping people one at a time.' It stresses that the help it tries to offer is not welfare," (McCarthy 32). While contestants who are prodded to vocalize their hardships are rewarded by the “philanthropic” offerings of the judges, the viewers/audience see the individual as redeemed through the show, and outside of the conditions that caused their circumstances.  

Curious about the behind-the-scenes aspect of Master Chef, I googled to find out if the producers and team behind the show perform tactics to induce trauma. What resulted in my search was a former contestant, Jessie Glenn, who never signed the show’s contract and exposed exceptionally distressing details that the contestants endure in order to qualify to be on the show. Glenn writes, “In the ‘MasterChef’ contract, which a casting director later told me was essentially identical to those of most reality competition shows, they asked me to agree to be subjected to physical and mental distress, to agree to have my medical history used in any way that they wanted and to use it in perpetuity, to agree that my family would likely not be contacted in the case of an emergency. They asked me to release the show and its employees from liability for any injury to myself from risks both known and unknown. They asked that I release them from liability from the social and economic losses that could result and to please note that the consequences could be substantial and could permanently change the future for me, my family, friends and significant others.” Glenn, a former contestant who never made the show, described how during her exit interview, she was subjected to a psychological exam where she was asked whether she harbored any thoughts about killing the judges or herself. Glenn disclosed that she kept in touch with many of the other contestants, who also described the psychological abuse they underwent during the show. A runner-up from season 3’s finale, Josh Parks, was diagnosed with bipolar disorder a week after the finale ended, and committed suicide a few weeks later. The insidious nature of reality TV shows like Master Chef, which promote the idea of “making it” and proffer dreams achievable through hard work and determination, are in reality, a contrived theater that impose and exploit trauma under the guise of “undercover philanthropy.”


Core Response #2 -- Dan Hawkins

 

Core Response #2

I really appreciated McCarthy’s essay on Neoliberal reality TV, which articulated something that I felt and was disturbed by watching various makeover shows. In the span of time after I graduated college and was at home with my parents and unemployed, not sure of what I was going to do with my future, I watched two seasons of Netflix’s Queer Eye over a period of perhaps three days. At first, I enjoyed the show’s positivity – it was about growth and self-improvement, and I was searching for both at the time. However, by the end of the show, its true philosophy was clear: growth is a makeover and self-improvement is home improvement.

While Queer Eye is more active in its participants’ transformation than Random 1 as described by McCarthy, much remains the same: The “Fab Five” arrive at the home of the episode’s subject in a black SUV, affecting the image of a team of government agents. If McCarthy characterizes “citizen in the neoliberal state as a fundamentally infantile position” (36) then Queer Eye is the epitome of the neoliberal state: for the week’s duration in which the cast conducts their makeover, they are the subject’s adoptive parents. They buy them clothes, bring them to a salon, decide their style, teach them to cook and decorate their house. The participant cedes all control over to the cast.

An episode of Queer Eye follows a static formula of moving the participant from being pathetic to cosmetically dignified. When the cast tours their home, there are cutaway interview clips or offhanded comments remarking on the sad state of the place, the wardrobe, the kitchen, the decorations, etc. The solution to all of these, is, of course, purchasing. In a true neoliberal fashion, the Fab Five improve the life of the episode’s participant by buying clothes and furniture, wrapping them in a veneer of class ascendancy that is untouched by their actual economic status.

The “Theater of Suffering” that McCarthy identifies as being the driving force of reality TV is augmented in Queer Eye, which instead opts for a theater of shame in which the pitiable is gilded. Are the participants emotionally improved after the show? They’ve received a pep-talk and a TV appearance. Are they economically improved? They’ve been gifted expensive tailored clothes and a redesigned home – then they are gone, and the cast moves on to the next “miniature, spectacle-oriented relief effort” (37).

Core Post 3-- Michael Feinstein

 In Better Living Through Reality TV Laurie Ouellette and James Hay take up John Hartley’s idea of cultural citizenship and reality television programs as “citizenship games”. However, they depart from Hartley’s ideas on participatory reality programming like American Idol, (what Hartley calls “do-it-yourself” TV), as inherently “empowering” and “democratic” (where democratic specifically means self-governing. Instead, Ouellette and Hay see reality tv as “an objective of governmental rationality” (224). Accordingly, the media citizen created by reality TV is not so much self-created but rather inexorably tied to the structures and ideologies of government. The reality program 90 Day Fiancee, which airs on TLC, and chronicles multiple couples as one of the romantic partners (who has newly arrived in the United States from abroad) gains and lives on a temporary K-1 visa, is a perfect, nearly meta depiction of how reality TV creates citizenship and ultimately promotes a view of that citizenship that is formed by governmental institutions. The K-1 visa that is featured and discussed heavily on the show requires the foreigner who has received it to marry his or her fiancee (who is a US citizen) within ninety days of the visa being issued or they have to vacate the US and lose whatever status of citizenship that the K-1 afforded them. This ninety days, which the US government has (most likely arbitrarily) set as the time limit, gives—as the title would indicate— the entire show its’ structure and form. We begin viewing these international fiancees right around when one of them acquires this temporary citizenship and the season concludes at their marriage that will ultimately lead to a more permanent citizenship to the once-foreign citizen. This program’s format— which has been molded by US immigration policy— creates a literal vision of television creating citizenship. While the show is not technically Do-It-Yourself TV it does, like Ouellette and Hay assert, promote an understanding of citizenship as tied “to the games and experiments of government” (224).  The viewers of 90 Day Fiancee are forced to understand the foreign men and women on the show through this government-sponsored citizenship they are living with and ultimately the show’s rabid fanbase, who discuss the show in depth on reddit (the participatory aspect of the show), end up judging each couple based on who they believe are legitimate—and thus deserving of citizenship by the rules of US immigration policy— and whose citizenship is based on false pretense and thus illegitimate and in need of termination by the US government.   Of course, like most reality TV, the men and women depicted on 90 Day Fiancee are participants in the “theater of suffering” (18) that Anna McCarthy explores in her writing on reality television. In her essay, which built on the connection of reality tv to the concerns neoliberalism that were made by Ouellette and Hay, she cites Lauren Berlant defining a citizen as “a person traumatized by some aspect of life in the United States” (19) and this again is reflected in 90 Day Fiancee as the biggest issues that the tv couples have stem from anxiety over the ninety day time-frame and— most importantly— the fact that the visa stipulates that the foreign fiancee can’t work legally in the US until he is married and thus denying the couple a source of income.  The ugly fights, emotional breakdowns, and traumatic experiences that occur on the show aren’t just “a cartoon version of a crisis in U.S. citizenship”, as Berlant describes some of the affects of neoliberalism, but a literal one directly caused by the temporary citizenship that was issued by the US and stamped by TV. 

Supplemental Post #1-Tiana Williams

**Disclaimer: Below is a somewhat random string of thoughts that are somewhat undeveloped but also correlated in my brain***




Oulette/Hay’s reading for this week provided an interesting framework for us to think about audience participation; with the transition from on-demand watching that provided networks the ability to track viewer habits to the current landscape in which we find ourselves with streaming platforms that are never-ending. But most notably, I found it interesting that Oulette/Hay’s construction/formulation of what entails audience participation focuses on less (while also more) interactive forms than what was covered in our week on audience, (particularly with the discussion of fan sites and TWop), as well as its specific look at the close ties between public and private enactments of “democracy.” Specifically, Oulette/Hay’s approach to situate audience participation/interaction within the workings of a neoliberal ideology was extremely illuminating for me, especially in chronicling the role of reality TV in replicating political processes that produce social inequities. Along with other string of thoughts that this reading brought to mind, Oulette/Hay’s discussion of television and its role in the political process made me think of the “advent” of technology's influence on electoral politics—for instance the impact of Franklin D. Roosevelt’s fireside chats (via radio) and the first televised presidential debate in 1960 (which is historically credited to have been a strong deciding factor in JFK’s victory). 


 Strings/Bui argued in their text on gender and racial realness in Ru Paul’s Drag Race that authenticity and “realness” equate a sense of familiarity with specific racial representations that need not be contested within drag culture (while gender as a social construction is demystified), and this reading in relation to Oulette/Hay's text brought up this question of authenticity within the political arena —for the individuals in the Oulette/Hay reading that stated that their American Idol vote had more weight than their presidential vote in the election, I started to wonder how TV

“democratic processes” foster the "illusion" of impact as a result of the voting process. As stated in the

Oulette/Hay reading: “by enacting democracy through private associations only certain citizens/members get

to operate these technologies and to vote on who is included and who is excluded” (216), as seen most notably

with mishaps in American Idol call-in voting processes. Outlette/Hay draw connections between TV networks'

voting processes and the often racist, classist, and sexist disenfranchisement processes of U.S. national/local

governments that are still ongoing today, but perhaps in more obscure ways.

Core Post #2 - Sabina

So this week is especially fun for me because I do work on RuPaul’s Drag Race (RPDR or Drag Race) and am always looking for more texts that critically discuss this show. What I found especially interesting about “She’s Not Acting, She Is” by Strings and Bui was the question of “passing”, in this case not in relation to gender, but race (and ethnicity). I have never been able to put into words what it is like to watch some of the contestants play with race in this way, but Strings and Bui do it so effortlessly. “Unfortunately, this racial rigidity remakes race into the biologically fixed category from which gender has just escaped. In other words, race is naturalized even as gender is destabilized” (832). As Strings and Bui note, white and Asian contestants see race (and ethnicity) “as a mutable characteristic” (832) while the Black, and brown (non-white Latine, Native/Indigenous, etc) contestants do not have the same ability to “change race” due to the way the judges force them into racialized boxes. 


Switching gears a little, I found Anna McCarthy’s discussion of “trauma” in “Reality Television: a Neoliberal Theater of Suffering” to connect pretty well to what I’ve observed on Drag Race in the contestants' confessionals, RuPaul’s werk room walkthroughs, and an end of season segment where RuPaul asks the remaining contestants to speak to their younger selves. “Indeed, the forms of violence and mutilation routinely displayed on reality television immediately spring to mind as ideal sources for such a project of witnessing. It seems to me that it’s impossible to talk about trauma’s place in reality television without talking about torture and violation” (30). What this immediately made me think about was an early example of this is from season 5, episode 7 “RuPaul Roast” when contestant Roxxxy Andrews breaks down on stage after a lipsync against Alyssa Edwards to Willow’s “Whip My Hair”. In this exchange, Roxxxy begins to cry, overwhelmed with emotions, and RuPaul probes her to share what she’s feeling. Roxxxy discusses not feeling wanted as a child and ultimately shares that her mother left her and her sister at a bus stop when she was three, using this as justification for her “strong character”. RuPaul responds in an encouraging and loving way, speaking to the queer community as a whole, saying, “You are so welcome here. You know we, as gay people, we get to choose our family. You know, we get to choose the people that we’re around. You know what I’m saying? I am your family. We are a family here.” RuPaul echoes this sentiment of “chosen family” echoing alternative forms of kinship proposed by queer theorists for years. The runny makeup, the crying, and RuPaul’s visible return to character add to the authenticity of the scene, making it feel like a real moment between these two people and not just a scene on tv. Now, this type of production is exploitative and a violation, but seemingly integral to the production of reality television. Where I find that this theater of suffering, and by extension the consumption of personal crisis, comes into play is the reaction by the fans. 


When I searched Google for “Roxxxy Andrews bus stop speech” to remind myself what exactly she said, the first video that popped up was “Bus stop roxxxy Andrews LOL” (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=He3PicN5wnM) . This is a 16-second fan-edited video with 171,000 views that splits Roxxxy Andrews’ speech with a previous video of RuPaul laughing while saying, “That’s funny, tell it again!”. Recommended videos included “Roxxxy Andrews/Say So mashup” and “8 Most Emotional Moments on RuPaul’s Drag Race” but I couldn’t find a video that showed the scene as it aired on Logo without ultimately turning to (British) Netflix. What this tells me is something in the production of Drag Race allows the queens to be violated and treated as a product meant for consumption. The authenticity of whatever the moment is doesn’t matter, the trauma doesn’t matter - what matters to production is how viral and sensational (memeable) the moment is, translating to the audience that the queens are an endless commodity. Which I guess might be the point? 


When read through a critical lens like McCarthy’s, the “Bus stop roxxxy Andrews LOL” video is a reflection of Drag Race’s exploitation of trauma: the audience comes to expect a traumatic storyline and fanvideo RuPaul applauds Roxxxy for making this happen and producing the scene, knowing that it will be it viral moment asking her to “tell it again”. A reliance on traumatic events to create a good storyline is inherent to reality television, sure, but as Strings and Bui alluded to, the way Drag Race churns out the personal trauma storyline reveals (ru-veals) how the exploitation of contestants' trauma is also incredibly racialized, prioritizing the emotions of white queens (and Asian queens) while continually “torturing” Black queens and other queens of color.

Core Response #3 - Lilla

 

While discussing the Random 1 in her article Reality Television: a Neoliberal Theater of Suffering, Anna McCarthy argues that instead of truly “helping traumatized others,” the reality show provides “an opportunity for middle-class liberals to experience ecstatic therapeutic growth” (32). While the premise of Random 1 is giving charity to those in need, instead, she continues, it is the subjects that donate their trauma to the show’s hosts “to help them advance their careers as philanthropist filmmakers” (32). This idea can be applied to several reality shows, from Extreme Makeover all the way to My Cat from Hell. These shows depict benevolent individuals committing lasting charitable acts to those in need. A new home, a new leg, a newly well-behaved cat. However, at the end of the day, Bruce from Random 1 might have a new leg, but he’s still unemployed and homeless. And while a family on Extreme Makeover might have their house rebuilt, they are often forced into having to sell the property later on, as they cannot afford the taxes, or because the renovations were done so cheaply that they need constant maintenance that proved unaffordable. 


These false happy endings speak to what McCarthy calls “messy implementation[s] of political ideals” in a world where trauma remains “ungovernable” (33). It implies that systemic issues such as poverty or homelessness can be resolved by random acts of kindness in a single day, and recipients of such benevolence should act grateful. “In taking away a reason for feeling bad,” McCarthy argues, they are placing pressure on the subject to feel good (35). Yet this idea oversimplifies and commodifies trauma, reducing it to a feel-good moment for the filmmakers and audience alike — it is all a spectacle at the expense of the most vulnerable. Therapeutic growth for middle-class liberals can only be experienced through exploitation of the working-class. 


We might also want to think about the audience here. These reality shows are heavily edited, staged, and inaccurate. Middle-class viewers might suspend their disbelief and just enjoy them in a self-congratulatory way, or as light entertainment. But viewers with less formal education, who are often the subjects of these makeovers, are more likely to take them at face value. And planting the idea that you, too, might experience these random acts of kindness creates a false sense of hope that deep-rooted social issues can be fixed within the snap of a finger.

Supplemental 4- Sabina

 Television and The Globe - What happens when a show goes international? Not to continue on this whole Drag Race trend, but I mean it is int...