Thursday, March 25, 2021

Core Post #4-- Michael Feinstein

  Angela McRobbie’s argument that postfeminism— and the pop culture that was created during 1990s and early 2000s— took feminism “into account” while simultaneously repudiating and denouncing it as a relic from the past (“spent force”), of course, made me consider whether the television we consume today would still qualify as postfeminist. Shows like Ally McBeal and Sex and the City, according to McRobbie, used “tropes of freedom and choice” (255) to give the impression that those things that first and second wave feminist were fighting for had already been successfully achieved and are thus were no longer a concern. The  individual sexual and professional empowerment of Ally McBeal and Carrie Bradshaw were smoke-screens covering the actual political and structural obstacles faced by women that it chose to ignore. As Sarah Banet-Weiser states, “the normalization of feminism has prevented it from existing as a discrete politics; rather it emerges as a kind of slogan or generalized “brand” (208). These ideas certainly still ring true for most of the television shows featuring strong, capable female leads that have come out in the years since Sex and the City went off the air. Shows like Girls, Euphoria, Fleabag, New Girl, and many others, center their stories around women with an unprecedented amount of freedom, choice, and access. They can say what they want and they can do what they want and—for the most part— these are freedoms that they just simply have, as opposed to ones they (or the generations of women before them) have had to earn. Additionally, historical dramas that do deal with systemic sexism and cultural misogyny, like Mad Men and The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, ultimately do the same work of presenting these struggles as antiquated and passe’. Even if these shows often do attempt to make parallels between the past and the present and viewers could read these political and structural critiques as somewhat relevant the hurdles that the women on the show have to overcome are still relegated to and obscured by the past. 

However, I think there are certain shows from the last 10 years that don’t neatly fall into this postfeminist bin as described by McRobbie. 30 Rock and Parks and Recreation both dealt with the structural and political forces that prevented the two shows’ leads from accomplishing their jobs. 30 Rock’s Liz Lemon, a show runner for a network late night sketch show, has to deal with the sexism and misogyny of both her boss and the mostly-male writing staff that she is in charge of. Additionally, Parks and Recreation’s Leslie Knope, a civil servant, is constantly depicted contending with the all-boys club of local politics and the show makes clear how she is held back in the political arena because she is a woman. However, these shows still both largely focus  on the “individual empowerment” of its’ characters and, one could argue, that the fact that these women are in these places of power in the first place negates certain feminist critiques. Still though, these shows and others like HBO’s Blackish, I May Destroy You, and Veep not only take feminism into account but also seem to engage with the idea that gender equality has not been fully achieved and there is still some ways to go. 

Supplemental Post #2-Tiana Williams

This week after rewatching the pilot episode for Insecure, I started looking into various assessments/opinions of the show as feminist as well as Issa Rae’s perspective on feminism. In an interview with Bust magazine, when discussing feminism, the article reads/quotes Rae saying-- 


 “My female friends are everything. They’re my support system. My rocks. We keep each other grounded and lift each other up. We definitely have a group chat going.” Leaning on and supporting other women is also connected to her identity as a feminist, though she wasn’t always at ease with the word. “I probably first became aware of the term ‘feminism’ in high school. I didn’t really identify with it because it just felt very white. I didn’t take the time to really explore it. In college, I discovered Alice Walker’s version of feminism—womanism. The word feminism still has a tinge of whiteness to it, but I understand the definition of the word now. I identify as a feminist because that’s what I believe in.”

Although Issa Rae doesn’t go deeper into her understanding of being a feminist (or perhaps the interviewer just didn’t probe) and how her own definition is directly influenced by Alice Walker’s definition of a womanist, it seems as though Rae understands feminism to be a source of empowerment and community, while also identifying feminism as “very white,” insinuating the exclusive nature of the term. In any case, it seems that Rae might not have fully articulated exactly how she specifically employs the term, especially in a political sense. Going back to the show’s pilot episode in which Issa Dee is shown at one point singing to her best friend Molly, “Nobody wants you cus you got a broken pussy,” I kept thinking back to Shoniqua Roach’s work on black pussy power and actress Pam Grier’s use of black pussy power in her films that enables her to “resist racialized gendered sexual subjection and tap into modes of erotic agency otherwise denied to her”(Roach, 10). Roach theorizes this by placing importance on “moving away from delimited understandings of pussy as female genitalia or an objectified entity of female sexuality” and in mobilizing black queer feminist thought in relation to black sex and gender. In watching the pilot episode of Insecure with Roach’s and Jess Butler’s texts in mind, I found the different abstractions of “pussy” and “power” within this particular moment in Insecure (compared with Roach’s text) really interesting. The episode in many ways “takes feminism into account” (McRobbie) in “normalizing post-feminist gender anxieties” (McRobbie, 262) by representing one of the main characters, Molly, as a successful, outspoken attorney who despite all of her career successes, is apparently unable to secure a man due to her “broken pussy.” Roach on the other hand discusses “black pussy’s discursive connection to black feminine sexuality” that  “animates the insurgent potential of black pussy power to secure nominal black freedoms in the face of state-sanctioned infringements on black erotic life.” Roach's explication of the pussy and its power appears more political than Insecure's joke within the pilot, but the question that still remains about this particular aspect of the episode, for me at least, is what does having a broken pussy imply and what does its fixing allow for? Is the type of power the emerges within its reconstruction similar to the insurgent erotic potential that Roach discusses in her work or is it simply to cater to the needs of men by presenting oneself as worthy of marriage within a heteronormative framework?

Georgina Gonsalves- Core post #3 (Post Feminism)

 Referring to McRobbie-

As time has gone by since the feminism movement gained movement in 1990, the argument has shifted from Sexism to Self Choice. Over the last few generations, opinions have shifted greatly, specifically in the use of female bodies in advertising and media. For example, McRobbie mentions an ad with a supermodel in lingerie in a car commercial. This is in my opinion very relevant to the current generation. During the feminist movement, this was seen as sexist and objectifying, but some opinions in the younger generation would consider this empowering, as a form of female success, because this model CHOSE to present herself this way, this represents an entire generation of women who emphasize and support women's rights to chose in every aspect of their lives without judgement. Especially in a time that is "post-Me Too Movement", this has strengthened the emphasis on women's right to chose, as well as bringing the importance of consent forward. The Me Too Movement shed light on the despicable acts of sexual harassment, assault, and manipulation of women in the entertainment industry. This created a wave of female empowerment in a different way that feminism did, women are now more empowered by flaunting their bodies and support body positivity; choosing for themselves how to live, what to wear, and not to feel shame or give any means of consent by what they choose to wear. A point made by McRobbie in relevance to this, a striptease can be seen as female exploitation in the eyes of a feminist, while post-feminists would see this an an act of choice. 

In my opinion, I don't believe feminism has become undone because the feminism movement was much more than sexuality. Efforts are still being made for equal pay (though unequal pay still happens often), women are fighting for reproductive rights more than ever, and women are achieving high levels of success continuously. Though it may be frowned upon by more traditional feminists, I believe that the women's right to choose is empowering. Women have always had such strong expectations and double standards, and are frowned upon anytime those expectations are broken or not met, while men are not faced with nearly as many expectations, or at least not shamed the same way women are in terms of sexuality. Women being able to choose for themselves is empowering because it breaks traditional standards that women are expected to follow, it makes society more equal that women can embrace our sexuality if we so choose, like men have done all through history, and reject feelings of shame that women have been taught for generations since childhood and systemically reinforced in the outside adult world. Self choice is a new branch of freedom for women that began with the feminist movement. This new movement gives women more power as they are normalizing self choice and self expression in all aspects of their lives, and the freedom to live life outside of societal expectations and restrictions. 

Core Post 3 - Sabrina

 

One of the reasons I identify as non-binary is feeling alienated from feminine spaces. So these readings about the construction of femininity through a post-feminist lens were a fun time for me to think about in terms of what notions of the feminine are being created there. I absolutely want to acknowledge that I don’t think conversations around feminism and women have to include discussions of non-binary genders, and I don’t want to hijack a feminine space, but a lot of the discussions around post-feminism and different feminism in these essays felt intertwined with non-binary gender identification in the discussion of new forms of feminism or gender springing from a negative reaction to previous thoughts on femininity.

 

Speaking solely from my perspective, the process of discovering my gender identity began with being in female spaces, feeling too queer or too other for these spaces, and then seek genderqueer spaces that allow for different forms of inclusion and expression. In looking at these readings, I’m curious if looking at these spaces of heteronormative femininity that baffle me can generally be understood through these readings on post-feminism.

 

I most easily understood post-feminism as explained in Jess Butler’s essay. She talks about postfeminism as being rooted in the body and sexual difference, and outlines feminism as a commodity:

“As liberated consumers, contemporary young women self-consciously participate in a highly stylized “postfeminist masquerade” as a statement of personal choice (McRobbie 2009, 64). These women buy skinny jeans as a marker of their “progressive” gender ideals; they get pedicures and bikini waxes because they have the freedom to “choose” to engage in conven- tional femininity. The consumer-based logic of postfeminism conflates feminism and femininity, individualism and liberation, and consumption and activism to the extent that “women apparently choose to be seen as sexual objects because it suits their liberated interests” (Goldman, Heath, and Smith 1991, 338). Unchained from political activ- ism, postfeminism constructs gender as a consumer product that women can try on—and take off—as they choose.” (13)

Looking at that idea of taking it off and on, I just always want it off. And it’s not the entirety of femininity that I feel foreign from, though to have people acknowledge my non-binary identity I often push back against the feminine more than I actually feel matches the amount I wish to engage with the feminine in my self-identificaiton.

 

There was also some hints at this oppositional reaction to expectations of femininity in the McRobbie:

“Why do young women recoil in horror at the very idea of the feminist? To count as a girl today appears to require this kind of ritualistic denunciation, which in turn suggests that one strategy in the disempowering of feminism includes it being histori- cised and generationalised and thus easily rendered out of date.” (5)

“Thus the new female subject is, despite her freedom, called upon to be silent, to withhold critique, to count as a modern sophisticated girl, or indeed this withholding of critique is a condition of her freedom. There is quietude and complicity in the manners of generationally specific notions of cool, and more precisely an uncritical relation to dominant commercially produced sexual represen- tations which actively invoke hostility to assumed feminist positions from the past in order to endorse a new regime of sexual meanings based on female consent, equality, participation and pleasure, free of politics.” (7)

I’m overemphasizing the bits that explain why people don’t want to or don’t like to identify as a girl, but it seems like what this reading suggests makes people move away from feminism towards post-feminism is what makes me begin identifying as non-binary rather than as woman.

 

Basically, I feel like within these readings on different forms of feminism and different (negative) responses from one branch of feminism to another, I feel like there’s this reaction of femininity is confusing and I don’t understand it and don’t see the value in learning to engage with it when presented with the option to just not unpack all that. Then occupying this outside perspective it’s easier to see the ways in which gender gets tied up into, well, everything, and from there feel even more comfortable not wanting to engage there, or wanting to engage with a third option.

Jensen Supplemental Post #1

For this supplemental post, I wanted to talk about a couple of television miniseries that are among my favorites: Band of Brothers (2001), The Pacific (2010), and the upcoming Masters of the Air. Yes, for those of you who know me better, I am talking about WWII stuff again. Apologies that I have been re-watching these instead of the Twilight film series...

Regarding these series, I wished to discuss the theme of historical memory. The two which have been released so far, BoB and Pacific, depict the war from an American perspective, following the events of the global conflict from the points-of-view of an American paratrooper company and various individual Marines respectively. Both series utilize first hand descriptions of the battles and subsequent events, either through interviews with veterans (which were also included in the episodes) or nonfiction memoirs such as With the Old Breed: At Peleliu and Okinawa (1981). These elements lend a certain rhetorical ethos to the series, as horrors are made more real for the audience coming from those who experienced them and seeing how those experiences affected them in later life. This blend of fiction and nonfiction elements allows the viewer to experience the conflict from the perspective of an American fighter on the ground, and the decisions which had to be made by them seem rectified by the intense depictions of combat. 

That being said, there has been some critical disagreements surrounding these sorts of depictions of warfare. Perhaps the most controversial is that the limited perspective granted by these portrayals do not offer a holistic look at the overall complications and historical/political backgrounds which went into the conflict, offering in turn a biased perspective of the war. While certainly these series showcase a primarily American point of view, I would argue that the point of the series was to emphasize the emotional and physical toll which the events of the war had upon those who fought it, and it is assumed by the filmmaker that the viewer has a basic understanding of the events leading up to and during WWII. If the creators wanted to offer a more objective point of view, they would not have drawn from the personal/individual sources which they had. That being said, it is important to note that these series could have taken a deeper look into the trials which the civilian populations during the war suffered, as they are among the most negatively affected populations of such conflicts and are too often overlooked in the war film genre. 

I am super excited to see what Masters of the Air has to offer, and how the change in production companies (the first two being released by HBO, but with this being released through AppleTV) effects the content produced. 

Core Post #2 Kimberly Henry

In her paper, “For White Girls Only?” Jess Butler goes out of her way to delineate between post-feminism and third wave feminism, while still drawing connections between them; while she defines post-feminism through McRobbie as displacement, she characterizes third wave as an at least partially self-aware critique and expansion of second wave feminism, although it remains expressly neo-liberal (). It’s Butler’s view of the third wave as neoliberal that makes me wonder at the blurred lines between post and third wave feminism today. McRobbie describes some of the main tenets of post-feminism as the valorization of individual choice, of femininity as a commodity for purchase, making the ideal female subject/citizen of post feminism an active participant in consumer economy. This description is neoliberal in essence, focusing heavily on individual regulation and consumer democracy. But it makes me question is question is how then do 1990s conceptions of post feminism differ from post-2016 (let’s say) embodiments of third (or does #MeToo count as fourth?) wave feminism?

 

Although current feminist ideology far from assumes guaranteed gender equality, the rest of the traits listed by Butler as characteristic of post-feminist rhetoric are front and center in contemporary feminism: Emphasis on “sexual subjectification,” self-surveillance repackaged as self-care, and activism as a purchasable commodity. Beyond these similarities, the figures of color which Butler listed as icons of post-feminism—or those who still maintain relevance—have transformed into “feminist icons.”

 

This point for me to the most intriguing—and in some ways troubling—development since the readings’ publications. The relative disappearance of post-feminism, least as a ubiquitous alternative to/displacement of feminism.  To claim gender equality has been achieved in a post-2016 America will likely mark you as naïve or one of the few women permitted on Fox News/OANN—ie. Conservatice. Instead of post-feminism, intersection, politically active (or rather performative) feminism is the presumed baseline, the new ideal of female subject-citizenship. This feminism, however, maintains the consumerist, representational focus of post-feminism, however, now it has absorbed the the radical/alternative practices of marginalized groups, such as magical thinking/ritual. Sage and crystals are all for sale on Instagram as self-care practice paraphernalia, along with shirts reading “Empowered Women Empower Women.” In some ways I find it necessary to counter my own point here, and mention that the products of these profits often purport to support some feminist political cause (as did my purchase of a Nasty Woman t-shirt in January 2017). However this consumer-feminist-activism only furthers the neoliberal trend of moving social/feminist welfare toward the private sector.

Core Response #5 - Laura

 “Thus, the contemporary young woman, self-reflexive and gender-aware, finds herself ‘confined to the topographies of an unsustainable self-hood, deprived of the possibilities of feminist sociality, and deeply invested in achieving an illusory identity defined according to a rigidly enforced scale of feminine attributes’” (Butler, quoting McRobbie, 46).

Hoo boy do I feel called out. Reading these texts has forced me to do the thing I like least in the world: look back on my early adolescence, a painful era during which I was solidly in the postfeminist camp. When I was growing up, it was very important to my parents (who came of age during second-wave feminism) that I not wear makeup or heels or revealing clothing, both because those are classic things for parents to get upset over and because they are tools of capitalist patriarchy. But “liberated women don’t wear makeup” was a deeply, deeply unhelpful sentiment for insecure tween Laura who was surrounded by girls who did wear makeup and seemed confident and happy and drew the attention of boys. What I viewed as my mom’s feminism simply did not seem to describe my experience in the world.

I fully understand how twisted this mindset is: I was made to feel out of place because I didn’t meet mainstream beauty standards, an obviously feminist issue, and then I resented feminism for it. But I was in middle school, and the only thing I was thinking about was acceptance. Who cared about social justice? I was just trying to get through the goddam day. Thankfully, I grew out of it during high school, but I continue to feel that in discussions like this we sometimes fail to account for what it means to actually be on the receiving end of all of this shit, from both the feminist and post/non-feminist sides (and, for that matter, from all the other areas of discourse we’ve looked at in this class).

Butler says that “contemporary young women self-consciously participate in a highly stylized ‘postfeminist masquerade’ as a statement of personal choice,” that they buy skinny jeans or get pedicures “as a marker of their ‘progressive’ gender ideals…  because they have the freedom to ‘choose’ to engage in conventional femininity” (46). (Again, I just feel so called out.) This is an awful lot of generalization, isn’t it? These contemporary young women, have they truly bought into the idea that they don’t need feminism anymore? Or are they buying skinny jeans and getting pedicures because they have been made to feel deeply insecure about the way they look, and they know that taking these steps can help alleviate that insecurity even if it is ultimately reinforcing patriarchal norms? Besides, shopping is a fun and easy bonding activity with friends, especially female friends, and often the female friends I’ve gone shopping with are people with whom I’ve also had long and deep discussions about race and gender (there’s that feminist sociality for you, I guess). We do both.

I don’t fully disagree with Butler on any of this, to be clear; overall she’s clearly assigning more blame to the culture industry than to individual women. And I do really appreciate that she ends her piece by discussing Nicki Minaj as a potentially subversive figure. Part of my angst at these types of discussions is that very rarely do they offer a positive alternative to the problems they identify. If you’re going to tell me that every piece of film/television I consume is a neoliberal opiate, that’s fine, but I’m not going to just sit on my floor reading The Second Sex over and over until I die. You need to give me something to keep me going. I feel like it would be useful to identify more ways in which women, especially women of color, may be able to use mass media subversively instead of deterministically writing everything off as postfeminist.

Supplemental 4- Sabina

 Television and The Globe - What happens when a show goes international? Not to continue on this whole Drag Race trend, but I mean it is int...