Thursday, March 25, 2021

Core Response #5 - Andrea

I had too many thoughts inspired by the readings this week (rip to my Wonder Woman, Bridget Jones, and Hannah Montana drafts that came before this post), so I’ll try to wrangle some of my most significant conclusions on this week’s readings. For one, I appreciated Angela McRobbie’s breakdown of postfeminism, and I find her idea that postfeminism does not simply indicate the death of feminism but an afterlife in which “feminism [is] at some level transformed into a form of Gramscian common sense, while also fiercely repudiated,” really helpful in bringing these texts to our contemporary moment (256). This idea that feminism is taken as common sense really resonated with me and the media texts that interest me, and I think it makes clear the ways that contemporary media is able to give a wink and nudge to “outdated feminism,” to use McRobbie’s terminology, while also reinforcing the idea that individualism and “freedom of choice” require a move beyond feminism. I’m also fascinated by this idea of this postfeminist hatred for feminism according to McRobbie, and how vague notions of empowerment versus disempowerment fuel this strong animosity towards “outdated” feminism. 


In particular, this repudiation of feminism and the ironic engagement with outdated feminism reminded me of the old Carl’s Jr. commercials featuring supermodels eating burgers in the most sexually explicit ways possible (video). I had completely forgotten about these commercials from my childhood, and McRobbie’s text brought back the memories of bikini-clad models dripping sauce on their breasts and orgasming over burgers as she explored the concept of “self-consciously” or ironically “sexist ads” (259). I feel that this sort of ironic objectification reached a peak in the early 2000’s, and the proliferation of “commercial sexuality” coupled with narratives of “empowerment” lead to what Jess Butler defines as “the (imagined) success of the women’s movement, a sex-positive (and racially exclusive) feminist legacy, and the ever-expanding neoliberal celebrations of autonomy, individualism, and consumer choice” (41). I think these ideas of sexual liberation have manifested in similar yet different ways in contemporary media, for example, Bimbotok (the bimbo/himbo/thembo side of Tiktok) engages with this idea of sexual liberation and the freedom of choice over how one represents themself in the world (very heavily tied to consumer habits and clothes/makeup). I think Bimbotok is a pretty clear example of the ways postfeminism logic “conflates feminism and femininity, individualism and liberation, and consumption and activism,” according to Butler, however, I believe it more actively engages with feminist thought than outright repudiating or rejecting outdated feminism. Bimbotok definitely represents this sort of postfeminism tension the authors highlight this week, and it’s interesting to see the ways contemporary creators are speaking to these pervasive narratives of empowerment and sexual liberation. 


I’d like to think that we’ve moved beyond this sort of “ironic sexism,” however, I’m left questioning what place we’re at in this postfeminist environment. Despite the ways the authors this week clearly define intimate relationships between post-feminism, post-racism, and neoliberalism with white heteropatriarchy, I’m left wondering how postfeminism is represented in our contemporary moment in TV and film. I believe we’re at a strange moment in which feminism is taken as a sort of common-sense idea, yet there’s a new wave of “popular feminism” that many shows, particularly shows aimed at women and teens, embrace what Sara Banet-Weiser might refer to as “ambiguous diversity” in terms of gender and race. In shows today, (yes, I’m definitely thinking of Riverdale here), there are active attempts to explore what we might refer to as “outdated feminism,” yet almost everything is packaged in girl boss tropes. Is this just an extension of the postfeminism these authors explore or are we seeing something different? Is there still a sense of repudiation or hatred towards feminism, or are we just seeing fully coopted neoliberal politics now?

3/25 Core Response #4_Ann

The three readings this week on postfeminism are not only constantly in conversation with each other but also present postfeminism in relation to the proliferation of neoliberal thoughts and consumerism. All three authors see danger in labeling feminism (or any other “ism”) using the word “post-“, and as Sarah Banet-Weiser puts it: “this prefix implies that whatever it modifies is somehow over—postfeminism, for instance, suggests (and at times insists) not only that feminism is passe but also, more obliquely, that whatever goals feminism sought have been accomplished” (214). While the readings agree with each other on the definition of postfeminism, they took different ways to analyze this social phenomenon—Banet-Weiser’s piece discusses “diverse” children’s television; McRobbie’s speaks from a UK perspective and Butler’s talks about race and ruptures in postfeminism. These diverse approaches to the same topic of postfeminism in turn prove the ambivalence of this concept and its permeative nature. 

What I find most fascinating and most relevant today is Jess Butler’s theorization of the relationship between postfeminism and neoliberalism as well as the role race plays in rupturing postfeminism. Butler writes on the similarity between neoliberalism and postfeminism saying “both are structured by a ‘current of individualism’ that undermines notions of the social or political; both demand an autonomous, self-regulating, active subject” (45). This emphasis on “self-regulating, active subject” reminds me of the McCarthy article we read a while ago on governmentality where she invokes the “pastoral responsibilities of the state” in the discussion of reality television under neoliberalism (25). This connection is not hard to see since both authors recognize the increasing emphasis on individualism in today’s media climate, but this emphasis is definitely more devastating when Butler connects it with postfeminism. While the first and second waves of feminism were collective and political movements that brought women together, postfeminism (and part of third-wave feminism) seems to disintegrate the structure and connection made in the first two feminist movements. Although much of the Western society today is moving towards neoliberal individualism, I think women are especially vulnerable to neoliberal ideas precisely because the neoliberal influence is largely masked by postfeminism, where it claims buying certain products and having certain “flava” mark the success of feminism and confirm their individual identities. 

Another interesting point Butler made is the fact that race could be the incision point into disturbing the idea of postfeminism. Butler calls for “a complex, dynamic, and multilayered analysis” to unpack the multifaceted environment of postfeminism today (54). She identifies Nicki Minaj as one of the examples to disrupt the postfeminism that only includes middle-class white women and heterosexuality while excluding or assimilating any racial differences. While I think this is a great starting point to further the discussion on race and postfeminism, I also wonder if this example is enough. What exactly could be categorized as non-postfeminism in today’s media climate? All three readings today talk about the definition and even specific ways to identify postfeminism in popular culture, but rarely do they (except Butler) mention ways to combat this harmful concept. Does anti-postfeminism exist, if so what does it look like? Butler theorizes Nicki Minaj as someone who cannot be labeled by dominant ideologies thus rupturing postfeminism, but not-labeling also brings up questions and problems. Does “not-labeling” equal liberation or is it just another kind of label? How can we, as media scholars, separate feminism from postfeminism? These are questions I’m still pondering myself. What’s more, I think the readings slightly glossed over a very important discussion of postfeminism in relation to neoliberalism—class. While all of the authors recognize class as a factor in the conversation of postfeminism, none of them really goes into talking about how class factors into the formation of postfeminism; especially how class difference may render certain demographics more susceptible to the images of postfeminism. 

Lastly, on a bit of a digressive journey, I would like to think briefly about the idea of postfeminism outside the Western world. All three authors today emphasize the generational difference between each wave of feminisms, but this generational difference is specific to the US or to the Western world. What would postfeminism look like when it is manifested in a country that did not experience the same waves of feminism, but, rather, just entered its first grass-roots feminist movement while it is also under a market economy? In this particular case, I’m thinking about China and the “me too” movement on Weibo that started alongside its Western counterpart in 2017. This movement opened some possibilities for Chinese women to discuss the inequality they experience in their everyday lives, and it also snowballed into a widespread discussion of feminism that has never happened before. Speaking from someone who still pays great attention to this movement (which is still going and has progressed quite a bit), I think this movement has raised great awareness on gender equality but it has also intertwined with the market economy and commercialism in China. Many brands and studios, after recognizing the size of this movement, have made efforts to change their slogans, to produce “female celebration” ads, and so on. These efforts, seemingly harmless, positive, and extremely well-received, do remind me of the idea of postfeminism where “feminism” becomes a commodified concept to be used in selling products. How can we reconcile this wonderful grass-roots feminist movement with the postfeminism ideals embedded in them? Can feminism exist outside commercialism in the Chinese context? These are questions I kept asking myself when reading this week’s readings. One last thing I wanted to mention before I stop rambling is the recent court case of Xianzi VS. Zhujun. This is one of the first sexual harassment cases where the defendant is a celebrity that went to court. While this case is still in progress and there is only a glimpse of hope in Xianzi winning, it has sparked small but resonant support nationwide. It is political actions like this that give me hope in combating postfeminism in today’s China. 

Colton Elzey Core Post #1 "[F]or male viewers tradition is restored"

Angela McRobbie's piece analyzing post-feminism presents several interesting concepts regarding the term and social movement generally as it is reflected in everyday life as well as within popular media. McRobbie described the ideology behind the post-feminist movement as existing through a form of "double entanglement", in which one must call back to the Big Brother roots of 1984 to apply double think, and accept both "the co-existence of neo-conservative values in relation to gender, sexuality and family life" as well as "liberalisation in regard to choice and diversity in domestic, sexual and kinship relations" (255-6).  In short, her essay suggests that post-feminism allows a space for feminist theory--which modern culture has radicalized in a negative connotation--to exist because it is recognized as an element of the past, outdated and historicized, or one that has been "taken into account", and such is required due to social pressures that have created a culture of repudiation of the term, rather than ambivalence. 

McRobbie's analysis drew from an array of advertisements as well as popular media narratives such as Bridget Jones and Sex in the City. Her discussion of TV advertisements--both involving glamorized female figures--as backing to an argument that supports a new view of feminism by undoing it. The concept of sexualized, objectification that feminism would originally oppose, is not done here because McRobbie explains that the modern generation understands irony and accepts freedom of expression, sexuality, and such as displays of freedom not control. However, what I would posit that her essay lacks, is a candid look at both of these ads for what they are: advertisements, aimed at garnering viewers, influencing commerce, and selling products. As she explains, for the hetero men in the car "tradition is restored", they are back to a space where they can gaze upon a female body without shame. McRobbie explains that this objectification is a positive form, and an element of post-feminism (displaying that freedom and status were achieved) because of the objectification, and the irony behind the display of skin, and that both adverts display this as the woman's choice to do so, thus presenting positive movement in the gender battle. However, again, these are ads, designed not as forms of self expression, but for the purpose of capitalism--and that showing a nationally recognized super model slowly removing clothing items as she slips into a beautiful sports car signals to the audience the benefits of owning that car.

In summary, I don't think analyzing the ads as displays of positive representations, or even elements of post-feminism where "the fight is over, and status has been achieved," is accurate, considering there is not narrative arc behind the objectification, simply the goal of marketing a product.    


*I should leave a note here that my background in feminist and post-feminist theory is very limited, so there's that. 





    

Core Post #4 Alexandria

 In the Sarah Banet-Weiser piece, I think I was kind of confused about the connections between “hip,” “urban” and “post racial.” I guess part of the reason why this threw me off was because I study popular music and in the context of many major music institutions, “urban” is a racially coded way to identify and separate black artists and their music from the pop mainstream. It’s something that has finally been receiving pushback in recent years. But I guess within Banet-Weiser’s context that the urban is used in a different way and that in many of the postfeminist tv examples she’s looking at, an urban setting connotes coolness and flavor, a kind of diversity that is geared towards consumerism as opposed to engagement with race. I wonder how Dora the Explorer would fare if it were introduced into today’s consumer context because she was “pan-Latina,” not rooted in any particular Latin American country or context. Raya and the Last Dragon is currently facing backlash because while it was set in a Southeast Asian context, they cast East Asian voice actors in the main roles. At the same time, it’s getting criticized for flattening the Southeast Asian diversity and vaguely representing it through the five tribes in the film. I wish we had more readings about Latinidad within TV representation, because I know that Latinx audiences have differing relationships to media representations as well.


It’s interesting to consider this piece in relation to Banet-Weiser’s later work on popular feminism in which she argues that pop culture has begun to co-opt feminism, making it a highly circulable, capitalist product, hollowed out of its original meaning. These three essays were helpful in terms of helping me to understand the context of postfeminism that led up to it, and some of the arguments over the overt sexuality of female pop stars that were happening during the time Butler wrote her piece (2013) are still very much in play today. Consider the YouTube comment section beneath Cardi B and Megan Thee Stallion’s recent performance of “WAP” at the Grammys. These arguments and contentions are still being played out in real time.


Supplemental Post #3- Rojeen

This week’s readings feel tangential to the theme from a few weeks ago on representation in television. In Butler’s piece, she offers a genealogy of feminism, going through the first, second, and third waves to elucidate the innerworkings of postfeminism. Butler writes, “And, just as it does for white women, postfeminism requires its nonwhite participants to reject political activism in favor of capitalist consumption and cultural visibility.” This sentence resonated with how I feel about inclusive representation in TV and on the big screen because representation is often limited for certain people or women of color who capitalize off hegemonic narratives that are exploitative (or even groundbreaking by disrupting certain tropes), yet ultimately contribute to neoliberalism. Is it really progressive if people or women of color are represented on TV if they push the cultural and capitalist commodity of feminism? I too fall for commodity feminism, purchasing garb that symbolizes my political stance while also understanding I contribute to capitalism by doing so. And while feminism/postfeminism often feels progressive in its dispelling of gender norms, Butler writes, “the women of color featured in the above representations clearly embody and enact postfeminism: they embrace femininity and the consumption of feminine goods; they espouse a vocabulary of independence, choice, empowerment, and sexual freedom; and they construct themselves (or are constructed by others) as heterosexual subjects.” The requirements of postfeminist discourse and manifestations on TV are to maintain the status quo by selling the feminist ideal without actually challenging the entangled systems of oppression. 

Core Post 3 - Sabina

This week’s theme on post-feminism really resonated with me as someone who studies various forms of queerness and race on television, similar to the discussions we’ve had in this class on “representation”. I’ve recently begun watching Sex and the City (whenever it is on tv) and something about it felt off to me. Then, Kim Catrall’s character Samantha said “For a sex columnist you have a limited view of sexuality” and something clicked. This show is NOT “sex positive” or “feminist” at all, in fact every episode reinforces white, heterosexual, “normative” behaviors despite claiming to be about women’s sexual freedom and the “power of being a woman in the city”. Most obvious, almost too obvious, is Carrie Bradshaw’s character. On the one hand, she is supposed to be emulated. She has her own column in a newspaper/magazine and has enough money to spend it on an apartment and various other material items (shoes). She is in control of her sexuality and she emulates this neoliberal “girl boss/climbing the ladder” idea. On the other hand, her desire for Mr. Big to notice her, to be with her, and to support her financially reinforces gender stereotypes and mainstream ideas of heteronormative femininity/womanhood. Carrie’s lack of support for her friends, as seen through her selfish behaviors, self-centered actions, and actions like interrupting Charlotte’s engagement news with her break up news shows her ultimate placement of a man above her “friends”, further pushing the idea that happiness can only be found in men. It reminds me of McRobbie’s quote, “Feminism is “taken into account,” but only to be shown to be no longer necessary.” The show considers feminism by talking about women’s sexual pleasures and women’s success in their careers/in a capitalist society, but ultimately tosses that all aside and centers men, platforming a neoliberal vision of feminism.

Core Post #4 - Lilla

 


In What’s Your Flava? Sarah Banet-Weiser describes Nickelodeon’s “carefully crafted industry identity as the ‘diversity channel’” (203). Banet-Weiser argues that championing girls and racial diversity is a lucrative business strategy for the channel, which has capitalized on the “historical invisibility and exclusion of diverse characters” (203). She later argues that, due to the pedagogical function of children’s TV, these shows in general tend to be more diverse than primetime television.

Yet I want to argue that showing female empowerment and racial diversity is much easier to do in children’s television, where women are desexualized and reduced to ‘girls.’ ‘Girls rule’ carries much fewer political connotation than ‘women rule,’ it is a simple and playful message that appears feminist on the surface level but truly just an empty phrase used as advertisement or to sell merchandise. Similarly, “strong, smart girls and multicultural casts” are simpler to depict on children’s shows that rarely depict racial inequality and present a postracial, postfeminist utopic world where all people — children — are treated equally (218). Sure, these depictions are healthy in that they teach children to treat people the same, but they are simplistic and should not be treated as progressive.

To me, the very idea of “empowering” children is somewhat problematic, as how often do children recognize they are oppressed? They might recognize being treated differently, but are oblivious to the systems upholding their oppression. It is very rare that shows even acknowledge racism or sexism — Disney’s That’s So Raven was a rare and early example — but even when they do, it tends to be teen, and not children’s shows. Of course, that is not to say that Nickelodeon should stop its diversity initiative. Sure, it’s a sly business practice that is “good business,” but any diversity is better than no diversity. The only issue is its self-congratulatory nature, in that diversity in children’s programming is not as radical as it seems.

Supplemental 4- Sabina

 Television and The Globe - What happens when a show goes international? Not to continue on this whole Drag Race trend, but I mean it is int...