Sunday, April 4, 2021

Peripheral Post #5 - Sebastian

    In his essay, “The Cultural Logic of Media Convergence,” Henry Jenkins makes an interesting point about the film The Truman Show. As he observes, the film is all about “media exploitation”; Truman Burbank’s entire life is broadcast as an elaborate reality television show without his knowledge or consent (Jenkins 37). Yet Jenkins expresses frustration with the film’s conclusion, wherein Truman insists on leaving the show so that he can finally enter “the real world.” Jenkins posits that it might actually be more productive and optimistic for Truman to “stay on the air, generating his own content and delivering his own message, exploiting the media for his own purposes” (37). As far as metaphors go, I understand where Jenkins is coming from here. Rather than merely rejecting media when we learn it is controlled by neoliberal capitalism, he contends that we should enact resistance within these structures by finding ways in which we can make that media serve our own (presumably anti-capitalist) interests. Indeed, Jenkins’ formulation even seems to subtly imply that the path of complete rejection is also often the path of apathy.

    While I appreciate the desire to enact resistance not just from without but also from within, I wish that Jenkins more thoroughly explored how this internal form of resistance would work. The previous Jenkins essay that we read for this class, “Star Trek Rerun, Reread, Rewritten,” seemed to point towards fandom as more akin to resistance from without; fans take the texts that fuel the fandom, “remaking them in their own image, forcing them to respond to their needs and to gratify their desires” (490). This isn’t entirely dissimilar to what I think Jenkins is getting at with his Truman Show metaphor, but the experiences of the Stark Trek fans seem to be predicated on a more private and personal process that exists outside of the main corridors of media and communication in contrast to the active counterprogramming that he wants Truman to enact. Yet this seems to ignore the fact that not everyone can counterprogram with equal ease. While the rise of digital media has undoubtedly made filmmaking a cheaper and less unwieldy enterprise than it was a few decades ago, you still need to have a phone and a stable internet connection to upload your film to YouTube, for example. The ability to engage with the dominant modes of media and communication already entails a degree of privilege. Again, I want to be cautious here because I don’t wish to encourage the sort of apathy that Jenkins is trying to move beyond. But for those of us who are potentially in a comparable position to Truman, it seems worthwhile to ponder: What are our responsibilities? Given the role of privilege that I've just outlined, it seems to me that the mere act of “stay[ing] on the air, generating [our] own content and delivering [our] own message” is itself not inherently useful (Jenkins 37). Rather, how we achieve this and what message we transmit seems to warrant a great deal of further consideration.

Saturday, April 3, 2021

Peripheral Post IV -JAE-

Peripheral Post IV


A few weeks back, news broke concerning the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) being sued by citizens of 新疆 (Xinjiang province) in northwestern China. The news source was The Global Times, a news organization sanctioned by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). And on April 1st, 2021 The New York Times confirmed that a BBC correspondent left Beijing, to seek sanctuary in Taipei, due to threats to his physical safety, in addition to a mounting propaganda campaign against him and his employer the BBC. Furthermore, in recent years, the CCP has grown aggressive towards institutions reporting negative, or critical, stories of treatment of the 回族 (Uyghur ethnic group) that mostly call Xinjiang province home. The CCP and Global Times argue that the U.K. is weaponizing their news media to demonize China as well as spreading imperialism through global human rights discourses. In return, the BBC and New York Times assert that the CCP is producing disinformation campaigns that conceal abuses of Uygher people and other voices of unrest. Such as 香港人 (People of Hong Kong) who have protested in 2014 (購物/shopping protests) and again in 2019-2020 (Umbrella movement). Yet, the unrest within news media in China, Hong Kong, the U.K, and even the U.S. have led to interesting changes in news reporting conventions. 


Social media platforms have become a bastion for independent formal news reporting. But 2020 saw a notable proliferation of news personalities taking to Instagram, Twitter, YouTube, and TikTok to distribute news faster and more directly than would be possible within a traditional news outlet. This is partly due to the bureaucratic designs of traditional news outlets, and partly due to being able to circumvent the political and corporate agendas of traditional news outlets. In this class, we have discussed at length how TV possesses the ability to respond to culture as well as the ability to shape culture through discourse production/destruction. The genre of television news programming is arguably one of the most powerful in terms of influencing the imaginaries of the citizenry; news programming is privileged, by the beliefs of its viewers, to always be true. But, the truths in news programming are still subject to discursive framing and censorship. Additionally, the turn to social media platforms as a means to mediate discursive influence isn’t foolproof. The reporters have selected the stories they report on, which means these stories have been privileged, based on the reporter’s sensibilities, as being important enough to report on. Yet, in the end, important stories can and will still go unreported, unseen, unnoticed, though these facts should be what inspires innovation in news reporting to minimize oversight as much as one can. 

 

Friday, April 2, 2021

Core Response #4 – Max Berwald

 


I thought the Mittell reading, “From Cop Shows to Cartoons in American Culture,” did a good job explaining the historical tension between genre studies– and broadly formal analysis– and cultural studies. I actually like the car metaphor. From that vantage point, I can especially appreciate “Techno-Soap!” A comparative type of formal analysis is being deployed here at the service of cultural studies. In that chapter, issues of gender, for instance, are centered, but not in the sense you would expect them to be centered in something like, say, the Carroll book described. It’s formal analysis with frequent recourse to broader cultural concerns that are often, but not necessarily, rooted in other media texts. 


In the Feuerian sense, we can likewise see the narrative baroque mode that Kackman identifies in Lost as the object of a kind of meta-formal analysis that draws the viewer into the equation. For Kackman, Lost’s narrative complexity is both a form of “internal marking” (as Mittell puts it, describing Feuer’s perspective) and something that comes from without and is manifested in viewing practice. That is, it is something that happens through and during interpretation:


“Complexity isn’t just something we find in a text; it’s something we bring to a text– and our recognition of certain characters as meaningfully conflicted, their narrative and moral dilemmas agonizingly or beguilingly puzzling, is a cultural identification. I’d like to see us talk more about melodrama and contemporary quality television not just as an ameliorative, cathartic symbolic resolution of social anxieties, but as a mechanism for the registering of political dreams.” (Kackman)


Looping back to the Mittell, I appreciated the problematization of genre as category: is this a quality that certain texts partake of, or something brought interpretively to texts? When Mittell writes, “While the members constituting a category might all possess some inherent trait binding them into the category… there is nothing intrinsic about the category itself,” it seems to me that there’s a solution within reach: genres describe clusters of interpretive practices. So the horror film may feature a monster (what is or is not a monster is certainly cultural) but it may also be a film featuring scenes that frighten one. Whichever meaning of “horror film” one is referring to will likely work in conversation, and likewise we can imagine they carry relatively well in industrial settings. (Whichever definition is primary in the speaker’s mind– and it may be that this would not be clear, upon reflection, to the speaker themself– the others might well be hanging around as secondary concerns or associations. If my friend describes a film as a “horror movie,” meaning by that designation that the film includes monsters, and I interpret it instead as “a film with scenes that will frighten me,” and then later a monster appears in that film, I will not feel that I have guessed wrong, because these interpretive moments (the recognition of a monster) or practices (the paying of attention to something that is frightening) are linked. When we introduce different cultural foci between which these interpretive moments and practices take place, I think we get to the Foucauldian picture that Mittell moves to as the chapter progresses.) Mind you, I don’t feel clever as I write this; I’m only trying to come to a full understanding of the problem posed by genre. 


“But by decentering the text as the site of generic essence, a potential problem emerges– if genes are categories that do not emerge from intrinsic textual features, then isn’t any system of categorization potentially a genre?” 


Yes! I fail to see the problem here. Of course, in the same way Mittell recognizes Cop Rock as a hybrid of the cop show and the music video, a novel interpretive practice may well constitute a novel genre. That doesn’t mean it will be popular or widely recognized, but we’re in the realm of cultural formations: what’s universal? I think Mittell hits on this when he himself writes that the “oater” failed to become a “generic label” while “soap opera” was able to “transcend its original usage as trade journal shorthand.” That is, one of these terms became popular and recognized and the other did not.

Thursday, April 1, 2021

Supplemental Response #4_Ann

 *Spoiler alert; I’m briefly mentioning WandaVision in this post but I will try avoiding the plot. However, if you don’t want to know anything from the show then please skip paragraph 3.

I really enjoyed this week’s readings since they brought together many ideas we have discussed in the past weeks. Genre, to me, is something that is ever-present and always in the background when talking about media, and this week’s readings (especially Jason Mittell’s piece) really made clear that genre is also something that’s both influencing and defined by contemporary culture(s). What’s more, melodrama, as argued by almost all the authors this week, is extremely important in understanding the television genre. 


I started with Jane Feuer's “Melodrama, Serial Form and Television Today” among the readings and I really enjoyed her theorization of the “excess” melodrama creates. She writes: “Despite the changing theoretical stances, all see the excess not merely as aesthetic but as ideological, opening up a textual space which may be read against the seemingly hegemonic surface” (8). She continues to talk about the excess in set design, acting as well as the television form, and provides alternative readings against the dominant ideology. What this discussion reminds me of is Newcomb and Hirsch’s idea of “culture forum” (I know, I reference them a lot but I really like that week’s readings), which considers television as a medium—albeit in its very early form—as the key to a multi-faceted and subversive cultural discussion. While I still think this idea is a little naive, my opinion changed a bit after reading Feur’s article on melodrama. The way she finds excess in both melodrama’s aesthetics and in its ideologies makes me rethink the validity of culture forum as something that may actually exist when the audience is in conversation with the genre. This also echoes Michael Kackman’s brief mentioning of “quality audience” in his piece where I think—if such a demographic of audience exists—genre-conscious is one of their defining qualities. 


I also think Feur’s analysis on melodrama is in conversation with Michael Kackman’s “Quality Television, Melodrama, and Cultural Complexity” very well. Both of them (as well as Tara’s piece) recognize melodrama as something indispensable in analyzing television, especially recent ones. This brings me to my discursive thoughts today: what about the Marvel universe—or maybe I should call it the new Marvel television empire—and its relationship to genre, culture, and melodrama? Now I understand this is too big of a project to take on while writing a blog post, but I really want to talk a bit about Marvel’s new WandaVision because it is such an interesting intersection of quality television, cinema, and melodrama (also because I loved the show). First of all, we need to recognize that Marvel is still primarily understood as a theatrical film studio where their most prominent media are superhero films, with decent but not great performance in television shows like Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. and Marvel's Agent Carter. However, their recent television plan—including WandaVision, The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, and Loki—on Disney Plus does signal a monumental turn in the studio’s approach to both television and film. In some ways, Marvel is intentionally bridging the gap between television and film by, using Kackman’s words, “place[ing] it [television] in its ‘true’ aesthetic context – that of cinema”. However, aesthetics is not the only reason that Marvel, or specifically WandaVision, was successful. Rather, WandaVision stays very true to the serial form of television and it includes a lot of classic melodrama characteristics. The show, while it is still about superheroes, focuses more on recognizable melodramatic elements like the romance between Wanda and Vision, the grief Wanda is experiencing after the Blip, marriage problems, and the nuclear family as the stage where everything unfolds. In fact, all the actions, militaries, superhero abilities, and high-tech side characters—which are not often seen in melodramatic television—are in support of our understanding of Wanda and Vision’s romance and her struggle with her grief. Not only that, the show is eager to tell the audience that it categorizes itself as television: the 1950s TV frame ratio, the black and white photography (in some episodes), the tv-related episode titles, and the sudden insertion of nostalgic television ads all scream “you are watching television”. What’s interesting here is that these hyper-visible television characteristics actually help elevate WandaVision into the category of “quality television”. Because these elements are so obvious, the audience is propelled into reconstructing their understanding of the show; in turn—using Rick Altman who was briefly mentioned by Mittell— creates a new syntax unique to WandaVision. Mittell mentions briefly author Rick Altman and his theory of semantics/syntax in his article, and I want to point to the fact that the semantics of WandaVision is a complex mixture of sci-fi, horror, melodrama, and comedy (Altman, 12), thus having a stable syntax is crucial in constructing the show. 


This has been an absolute ramble on WandaVision and Marvel. In a way, WandaVision is extremely smart in recognizing itself as a television program while drawing its syntax from Marvel’s cinematic universe as well as melodrama. I want to end with a question on the relationship between cinema and television under today’s media climate. What Marvel has done is that it created a collection of films that are serialized with easter eggs, character crossovers, and complex plot developments. In a way, the MCU is a serialized television program with notable television "flow" as theorized by Raymond Williams. Now that Marvel is actually tapping into television, it is fascinating to think of how that may change both the genre definition of TV and cinema.


Work cited: Altman, Rick, “A Semantic/Syntactic Approach to Film Genre”, Cinema Journal, vol. 23, no. 3, 1984, p. 6-18.



Core Response #3 - Emma

I find the discussion in many of the readings for this week about “quality television” to be particularly relevant as television formats have evolved. As I discussed a bit in my response to Kallan’s post this week, I think the transition from 24(ish)-episode seasons to shorter seasons consisting of 8-13 episodes an interesting one that coincides in my mind with this shift from a more episodic, less “quality” tv, to a more serialized, more “quality” tv. Michael Kackman’s piece, “Lost: Quality Television, Melodrama, and Cultural Complexity,” was eye-opening for me in the discussion of “quality tv,” which I have often found to be lacking in some previous discussions of it. Now I know that it was lacking this discussion of gendered forms of genre in "quality tv".

Kackman outlines something I have had trouble articulating about shows like Lost, and that is “operational aesthetic”—shows that invite (and in many cases, demand) the viewer to marvel at the complexity of the writing and the plotting, a spectacle and thus kind of show in itself. He argues that “the operational aesthetic doesn’t come simply from observing the workings of a finely crafted watch, but from a sense that the product of its machinery will be something more broadly meaningful—it tells us what time it is.” This is something I remember struggling with when talk of how “great” Westworld was when it first came out; shows like Westworld and Lost are built not necessarily on the narrative itself, but on the complexity of that narrative. (That usually isn’t enough for me.)

Additionally, Kackman brings into focus the melodrama of Lost, which I found complementary to Tara McPherson’s discussion of 24. Like McPherson’s analysis of 24 as a “remasculinization of serialized melodrama” (174), Lost deploys the soap opera in ways beyond what Kackman argues. Kackman describes the melodramatic “sentimentality and excess” of both Jack revealing his feelings to Kate and his hyper-masculine self-discovery. Kackman also says that Lost centers on patriarchal conflicts, which I would argue coincides with Feuer’s description of “the domestic melodrama’s oft-noted tendency to portray all ideological conflicts in terms of the family” (14).

I’d also like to consider the serialized format itself as a melodramatic format, intrinsic to the soap opera. Lost is known for its use of the extremely serialized format, with each episode beginning with a catch-up reel of what you missed—and not just what you missed on the last episode, but what you may have missed four seasons ago. I might even argue that Lost popularized this extreme seriality. However, this extremely serial format, as well as the consistently unresolved narrative, is from melodramatic, “feminized” television. Instead I'd argue that Lost seemed to bring this particular type of confusing, extremely long-form serial format to the genre of “quality drama” in particular, but poaching it from the soap opera itself.

CORE POST #2 Colton Elzey

 (Full disclosure: I am using this blog post as an attempt to try and organize my thoughts on the numerous notes from Jason Mittell's chapter on "Television Genres as Cultural Categories." Some of it may make sense, and some of it will most likely be jumbled rambling. Read on at your own discretion.)


Jason Mittell's book Genre and Television is an insightful, in-depth discussion of genre conventions specified to the medium of television, written and released in 2004, at the height of cable TV about 10 years before the streaming giants took over. His first chapter discusses the complications, nuances, and difficulty in genre analysis, touching on several modes of the academic form, as well as their limitations generally alongside the need for alteration with the unique medium of television--noting that most genre study at the academic level is regarded towards literature and film, not cable TV. His work proposes that the most correct method for studying genre is not textual, nor historical, but discursive.

Mittell's reasoning is that other modes of genre analysis, thought insightful and worthy of attention, often miss the entirety of the category for various reasons. He explains that genre is more than just the "text" writing "there is a crucial difference between conceiving genre as a textual category and treating it like a textual component, a distinction that most genre studies elide." Only some elements of the texts would categorize them in their specified genre, and while "physical elements do not change...their categorization does, suggesting that the category itself emerges from the relationship between the elements it groups together and the cultural context in which it operates.” The category does not define what you are; your group defines what the category is, and the cultural context defines what traits group those people together. We have "race" distinctions based on skin color, a physical trait, but nothing on eye color (unless you are on Roshar), because the culture has deemed that significant. "Texts have many different components, but only some are activated into defining generic properties." Therefore, the culture and textual elements define genre categories.

He also delves into the issues of interpretive/historical (?) analysis in genre study. Mittell explains that just as you cannot analyze the internal components of a car from the 1920s to decipher what brand it is today, you cannot apply historical analysis to a piece of art for a genre analysis. As the culture, and community change, the genre style changes. He writes: "Yet many scholars treat genres as timeless essences defined by an inner core rather than constituted by changing cultural practices." Thus, historical readings must be careful to make broad assumptions that would only apply to specific historical contexts.

In the end, Jason Mittell explains: “Interpretive analyses tend to treat genres as ahistorical and static, ignoring the ways genres shift and evolve in relation to their cultural contexts." They are often oversimplified. Therefore, genre is a conceptual category formed by cultural practices, and not inherent to elements of the text itself that the genre has categorized. The most proper form of genre analysis should be discursive, analyzing the elements that surround the media text in exhibition, production, cultural history and memory, context. 

Genre is more than the story; the text is not a genre. Genre is the interpretation of a culture's method for telling that style of a story. 


Phew. 







Core Post #3 - Dan Hawkins

 

Recently, I got into an argument with some strangers on the Internet on the nature of genre. It was in an RPG discord filed under the “Other media” subchannel. In increasingly aggressive tones, we went back and forth on the value of genre; the other posters believed (foolishly, in my opinion) that an understanding of genre is either unrelated to or actively impeding one’s understanding of a particular text. I strongly argued the opposite, that understanding the forms and function of genre elevates how we interpret and approach media. Being an internet discussion, I eventually gave up and nobody was convinced of anything other than each other’s idiocy.

In light of that awful interaction, I enjoyed Jason Mittell’s “Television Genres as Cultural Categories.” I’ve spent a lot of thought on how genre operates in videogames, which I believe is in some ways even more convoluted than the problems with television genres that Mittell describes. There remains the industrial element of genre construction: the size, structure and relationship to publishing of a game developer all affect its monetization practice, narrative and mechanical scope, platform and controls—all of which in turn affect a game’s genres. The plural of genres is an additional complication -- games tend to have two axes of genre: the textual genre that describes the content, aesthetic, and style with which we are more likely to be familiar (science-fiction, romance, mystery, etc). This genre is then interpreted by the other axis of genre, the procedural genre – the categories of mechanics, systems, and logic that form how the game is actually played. Platformer, first person shooter, 4X Strategy, Visual Novel, puzzle are all formal categories that affect the mediation between the text and the player. To give a random example, Halo and Mass Effect are both sweeping science-fiction epics told through action, but the former’s genre of a first-person shooter causes it function radically different than the latter’s role-playing game form.

Personally, I find Mittell’s arguments for understanding genre as “Cultural Practice” and “Situated within Larger Systems of Cultural Hierarchies and Power Relations” to be especially persuasive. Particularly in videogames, genre is almost inseparable from not just the cultural but the industrial processes that created them. Metroidvania, Souls-like, Rogue-likes, are all understandings of genre that derive from specific works by particular developers. In some ways, the distance between the culturally understood genre and the industry that created it is far smaller than other mediums. We don’t typically conceive of television shows as being “Lost-like” or “Thrones-like”. While I think that Mittell’s conception of genre as an object of analysis itself is useful, I think it needs to be re-examined and modified to be applicable to games.

Supplemental 4- Sabina

 Television and The Globe - What happens when a show goes international? Not to continue on this whole Drag Race trend, but I mean it is int...