Thursday, April 8, 2021

Core Response #5 - Kallan

    Although Caldwell addresses both narrative and reality TV in “Convergence Television”—e.g., using both Miami Vice and Temptation Island as examples in the same paragraph—his analysis of the “pitch aesthetic” (58) that shapes form and content seems especially apt for describing reality programming. Though this chapter was published in 2004, the “culture of production” (45) that he describes speaks quite well to my own (limited) experience working in reality TV in the 2010s. Caldwell writes, “Pitching is in many ways a kind of performance art. The ability to effectively reduce a thirty- or sixty- minute narrative to two or three short spoken sentences carries a premium in Hollywood” (58). I worked as a development researcher at a production company, which meant that I tried to come up with pitch-able concepts and prepared materials for someone else to actually pitch. All of my key tasks were guided by the pitch aesthetic. One of these tasks was to look at all of the shows currently airing on and recently greenlit by the networks we were targeting (i.e., regularly pitching shows to) and to sort them into categories by topic—e.g., for one channel: babies, weddings, wealthy families, big families, competition, etc. The next step was to note which shows, especially new shows, were clearly developed as (pitch-able!) combinations of established categories. For example, TLC had recently greenlit a show called Labor Games, which (I kid you not) combined giving birth with a game show (from a press release: “a race against nature as a camera crew surprises parents-to-be currently in labor, offering them the opportunity to win a nursery full of prizes before the baby is born” [emphasis mine!]). In addition to “birth + game show,” other combinations I found and noted on these spreadsheets included “makeover + medical” (Smile, a show about dental procedures), “dating + royalty” (Secret Princes), “dress shopping + weight” (Curvy Brides), “family + pranks” (Prank My Mom)—the list goes on. The point was to identify the categories/topics that these networks favored in order to come up with our own novel combinations of familiar categories (dress shopping + medical procedures, anyone?). The “‘just like X but with Y’ variant’” (58) process that Caldwell identifies, then, absolutely defines our operational mode. The “ideas” we prepared for pitching were more like formulas, both borne out of and easily describable by their topical hybridity (we can imagine the pitch for Curvy Brides, “just like Say Yes to the Dress but with elements of My 600Lb Life!”). 

    This process also ends up creating a feedback loop of sorts. Caldwell writes, “The industrial performance art of pitching inculcates the production culture with a clockwork-like dependence on endless variation/replication and a process of generic aggregation” (59). These repeated and remixed categories, the “endless variation/replication,” lead to both “excessive cross-genre hybridization” (58) and “generic aggregation,” with the creation of new bizarre sub-genres and sub-sub-genres, but they also produce a sameness within and across networks. Production companies pitch reliable categories and combinations-of-categories to networks, who seek out shows that fall into safe categories that their viewers already enjoy, and so on. Consequently, perhaps, while interning at a cable channel in an earlier phase of my reality-TV-"career", it dawned on me that all of the network’s shows were actually, at their core, the same show—the same type of characters, beats, arcs, musical cues etc.—just taking place in different settings (a pawn shop, a boat, Alaska). 


    All of this to say is that Caldwell’s call to examine how industrial and production practices/cultures shape and drive programming seems useful and wise. Although my anecdotes are undoubtedly less helpful that Caldwell’s analysis, I do takeaway from those experiences a grounded sense of the importance of considering industrial factors if we want to understand programming choices, "content," formats, aesthetics…at least on traditional cable networks (we didn’t pitch anything to streaming services! Maybe none of my takeaways matter anymore 😱!). 

Max – Supplemental Post 2

Nothing major to report here but I’ve been watching Death Note on Netflix. I’m enjoying it. It looks like there’s been an attempt at a live action adaptation which is fascinating as well, as the show seems to be thriving in its own very particular fantasy mode wherein the animation does heavy lifting. That’s probably the case with a lot of animations with fantasy dimensions. What is the drive to adapt successful animations into live action? And how does this differ across industrial contexts? 

I suppose the logic is that the live action Death Note will reach different audiences than the animated Death Note? In that sense it just reflects a difference in the way viewers self identify; there are presumably some viewers who are eager to consume anime and others for whom it’s a hang up, and the latter can be reached with a live action adaptation– the assumption being that a certain audience’s hangup is purely formal; that is, they would love the story of Death Note if only it were not animated. I wonder if we could also see the industrial practice (and its underlying assumptions, logics) as producing this audience division?


I’m also wondering how industrial assumptions about age track between, say, the US and Japan. For instance, I think the conventional logic regarding the Disney live action adaptations is that they’re caching in on the nostalgia aging viewers have for these narratives (having been exposed to them in childhood). 


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Death_Note_episodes

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_Note_(2015_TV_series)

Core Post V -JAE-

 Core Post V     

    

    Originally I was going to write about the TV show Glee (2009-2015) and link it to this week’s readings. I was 21 years old when the show premiered, but found resonance with many of the happenings that the fictional high school cast was experiencing. But then this phrase popped into my head, “Racers start your engines, and may the best drag queen win!” At that moment, I realized that RuPaul’s Drag Race (2009-present) might be even more ripe for this week’s themes as well as readings. 


    Drag Race launched on Logo, a Viacom subsidiary geared towards gay & lesbian audiences, with little to no content considering other gender and sexuality minorities. In these respects, as Caldwell noted with BET for Black audiences, Viacom was once again superficially buffering the content portfolios against accusations of lacking diversity. Logo was a premium cable channel, a competitor with Here TV, whose content was not syndicated onto Viacom’s more prolific channel offerings. Thus, limiting access to these diverse contents to the affluent who could afford to buy the channel, in addition to being privileged to know of its existence. Viacom was trying to capitalize on gays and lesbians being demographics stereotypically imbued with excessive expendable income. But, Drag Race would garner enough global attention that it was moved networks to VH1 during its eighth season as Logo was being phased out. 


    But the legacy of convergence strategies employed on Drag Race long preceded the network transfer to VH1. On seasons 1 & 2, the show enjoyed a sponsorship deal with Absolut vodka, where the top three or four queens would present outfits on the runway, representing flavors of Absolut vodka. Afterwards, the same queens filmed official Absolut vodka commercials that ran on Logo. Analogous deals were made with cosmetic brands, furniture brands, travel brands, and more. Additionally, the audition processes for early seasons (at least in Southern California) involved producers going to clubs and inviting local talent to submit audition tapes that meet specific criteria, and then promising queens would be invited to an in-person audition in LA. The contents from those queen’s tapes would be spliced together for a special “RuCap” recap episode of the queens that almost made the cut (I’m proud to say that footage I filmed for a friend’s audition is in the season 3 RuCap episode). 


    In some respects this cherry picking of content to get people excited for future audition cycles is arguably a form of textual poaching. Furthermore, since the network transfer to VH1, Drag Race has become increasingly responsive to fan criticism and demands, while requesting fan participation and promotion through hashtags and remix cultures. Not to mention, the show has international spin-offs without RuPaul, and international counterparts with RuPaul, two drag conventions (LA & NYC), an official podcast, streaming app deals beyond Viacom/Paramount+, and other productions which converge in ways other shows could only hope for. These developments echo and reflect many of the concerns Prof. Jenkins states about the media needing to embrace convergence opportunities to differentiate themselves and create more avenues to pursue longevity. In the end, for this particular show currently, more is more, but where does the line of fan fatigue and spreading too thin begin to emerge?    


Charlotte - Peripheral Post 2

 *This is meant to be a comment on Daniela's post about The Flight Attendant, but I wasn't able to comment on her post for some reason, so I'm posting it here instead*


I have been infuriated by this show as well! I was into it for a couple episodes and then it started to really grind my gears (also I watched this when it first came out so my thoughts are not completely fresh but my anger is still palpable). Watching other male antihero crime shows, the protagonist is depicted as incredibly smart and good at being a criminal (Walter White, Tony Soprano, etc.). In The Flight Attendant, which felt like a show trying to be ~feminist~ and ~progressive~, Cassie makes incredibly stupid decisions from the moment she discovers the body in the bed. She tries to run away from the FBI at the airport and then goes to the dead guy's office, seemingly with no plan. She behaves like she has never seen a single episode of any crime show. This is not to endorse the actions of male antiheroes, it's more just to say that, like Daniela said above, Cassie's whiteness protects her from facing any real consequences. She does not outfox anybody, she simply encounters a string of lucky coincidences that - surprise! - land her a new job with the FBI for the inevitable season two. I also took issue with how she decides to stop drinking and is immediately successful (feminism is all about choice babes and Cassie chooses happiness!). Never mind rehab or detox or the dangers of dying from unsupervised alcohol withdrawals; just stop drinking! I had this problem with The Queen's Gambit as well, and I think representing addiction/mental illness this way is potentially very harmful. 


Wednesday, April 7, 2021

Peripheral Post #4 - I need to take a break from HBO

 After a little over a month of consuming nothing but The Sopranos, I decided it was time to take a break from the Soprano universe I was spinning in (I imagine myself breathless, floating in the Soprano space) to watch another show on my HBO watchlist: The Flight Attendant. I was in the mood to watch something entertaining that didn't involve much thinking. (un)fortunately, I am a very critical consumer of media and my enjoyment of the show dropped by the third episode. 

I am somewhat of a hardcore binger where I cannot allow for any moments of silence so in moments of dog walking, exercise, and cooking, I am constantly consuming media. I finished the whole first season (8 episodes) in 2 days. Despite hating it by the third episode, a large narcissistic part of me wanted to finish it so I can properly hate on it for this blog post.

*SPOILER ALERT BEYOND THIS POINT SORRRYYYYYYYYYYY*

I am so dang tired of narcissistic white people (yes, that includes Tony Soprano). While I am incredibly thankful for the hard work of my boomer feminist foremamas, there is much work to be done. As with all great social movements in this country (at least), feminism has been co-opted and rebranded in a way that says it is intersectional, but what it does is quite the opposite. The Flight Attendant does include non white characters (so stoked to see Rosie Perez in a non-cop focused show!!!!!!), but what it does with them is really.... I don't know how else to describe it but neoliberal. There is one moment in the second or third episode where the Black female FBI agent, Kim Hammond (played by Merle Dandridge), tailing Kaley Cuoco's character Cassie tells off her white male FBI partner dude guy that he can get away with being brash, while she has to work 10 times harder because she is a Black women etc etc. I have to be honest, I super rolled my eyes at this part because a) a white man is writing this dialogue and b) a white man is writing this dialogue. This speech is starting to become a trope amongst white writers who are ~attempting~ to make a statement in solidarity with Black women, without actually doing any critical thinking such as: "hmmmmmmmm, maybe I should look into the incredibly racist/anti-black history of the FBI". While I am willing to somewhat forego this for the sake of seeing more melanin on screen, Hammond's role on the show, as a Black FBI agent, was to validate, valorize, and protect beautiful vibrant wonderful Cassie. In fact she is not the only Black character whose role it is to do so. Rosie Perez's character Megan Briscoe constantly tells Cassie how wonderful she is, while Cassie consistently dismisses Megan until the very last episode where she "empathizes" with her by saying "I know exactly how you feel" *insert vomit emoji here*. But wait, there's more! In Cassie's moment of crisis where she is faced with the decision of killing or being killed, her Black queer coworker Shane Evans (played by playwright Griffin Matthews), busts through the door and saves her by shooting the man that wonderful sexy innocent Cassie simply could not do. It turns out... Shane works for the CIA! What a wonderful white world Cassie lives in for real.

There is so much more I have to say, but like the title of this post says, I need to take a break from HBO. 

Supplemental Post 4 - Sabrina

I’m going to take my supplemental post this week to talk about a piece of TV news that’s probably only exciting to me: Survivor is back in production! I love watching the show with my friends and have fond memories of staying up “late” to watch it as a kid, but I’m also particularly fascinated by the set of circumstances that has led to it lasting this long as well as it not filming sooner than this during the pandemic. Though other shows have managed to change locations or enforce a quarantine to continue production into the pandemic, Survivor is currently only viably able to be produced in Fiji, in part because their sets and such are already there, and in parts because of the tax breaks they get for filming there. So there’s this somewhat problematic framework of the show where Americans go to a “deserted” island that appears only populated for the occasional reward challenge of experiencing the culture. And the show now finds itself locked into this framework by financial necessity (or at least unable to change its location easily; they could change the approach to it). The recurring location in addition to a desire to keep people watching for new gimmicks has also created a shift in the show where for the past several seasons the show has been subtitled around a premise (Game Changers, Winners at War, Millenials vs. Gen X) as opposed to its location (early seasons are named after locations like Gabon, Pearl Islands, Samoa, etc.). This shifts the setting to truly become a backdrop, instead of an exploration of a new place. There’s a sense of appreciation for the location (beautiful shots of the nature surrounding the players frame scenes), but in some ways this distance from the place that the show films in, a place that the show at this point cannot feasibly separate itself from. The government of Fiji is clearly happy to have the show film there or I doubt they’d be invited back season after season, and the show itself does at least acknowledge where they’re filming in a positive way (the host will bring it up on occasion), so I’m not sure if there’s a problem or not, but it’s interesting to look at the financial necessity of filming in Fiji to the show, as well as the extent to which the show does or does not acknowledge its setting. 

 

https://tvline.com/2021/03/22/survivor-season-41-production-resumes-fiji-jeff-probst-video/


Sunday, April 4, 2021

Supplemental Response #2: Julia

Our conversation in class this week got me thinking about a talk I attended at SCMS this year about cinema/TV and the law. One of the presenters had a paper on the politics of "copaganda" channeled through the queer characters portrayed on Brooklyn Nine-Nine. This paper really stuck with me, because this was a difficult point of contention I also encountered when watching the show, specifically with Rosa's coming-out as bisexual in Season 5. 

In recent narrative TV, bisexuality has found greater narrative representation, but mostly in the form of villainous antagonists. And while I absolutely love the Villanelles, Harley Quinns, and Annalise Keatings that exist on screen, sometimes it feels a bit restrictive to greater bisexual representation. Especially because this feeds into the issue of portraying bisexual characters as people who cheat and deceive, something that has been at the center of a lot of bi-phobic discourse in the past. So on the one hand, I feel so starved for bisexual representation through a character that isn't positioned as a manipulative villain, yet on the other hand characters like Rosa Diaz don't quite satisfy me either either. While I absolutely love Rosa for all her complexity and defiant stoicism, it feels difficult to sympathise with a character who is so multifaceted, yet whose main ambitions in life was to become a police officer. 

In the panel I attended, Jennifer Moorman also furthered this issue by denoting the fact that Rosa Diaz and Raymond Holt are both queer characters of color who thrive on the show as police officers. Their immense likability as characters invites queer spectators and spectators of color to identify with them, yet also leaving them to grapple with the fact that these characters uphold a system of oppression through their police work that often specifically targets queer POCs. This feels somewhat irresponsible and irreconcilable. 

Supplemental 4- Sabina

 Television and The Globe - What happens when a show goes international? Not to continue on this whole Drag Race trend, but I mean it is int...