Thursday, February 18, 2021

Supplemental Post 1 - Daniela Velazco

 The Andrejevic and Jenkins readings in particular through me into a real "throwback" to when I was younger and actually waited week to week for my favorite shows such as Heroes and Pushing Daisies to release new episodes. Both shows had an early demise (and in the case of Daisies, an unfair one), yet my intense love for them burned bright despite the fact that I did not have internet at the time. Instead I bought the DVDs so that I could ingest all the bonus features possible. I would use computer time at school to watch interviews on youtube (a new platform at the time!). And best of all, because I live in the c.lassiest city in America, I attended Comic Con almost every year from 2006-2013. My social anxiety flew out the door as I, an overweight and quiet fanatic, had found her people. As I finally gained access to the internet, my fanaticism grew, but it also allowed me to see a more unfavorable light of fan culture, specifically one involving cosplay. 

In "Star Trek Rerun, Reread, Rewritten" by Henry Jenkins III, Jenkins writes about how the greatest faux pas in fanfiction is "character rape", which Jenkins describes as "gross infidelity to the series" (Jenkins 487). I know this is a bit of a stretch, but what that got me thinking about one of the most disgusting things about fandoms, nerd culture, and life in general: the omission of Black and Latinx peoples. One of my favorite facets of nerd and con culture is the cosplay. Cosplay is a source of fantasy and escape, one in which the cosplayer is able to escape reality and enter the world of their favorite anime/film/series by wearing another character's shoes. I remember around 2010 or so there was a huge controversy on tumblr regarding a Black cosplayer dressing up as Sailor Mars from the popular anime Sailor Moon. The fanboys absolutely lost it. Insults were hurled at her in person and online regarding the fact that Sailor Mars "was not Black" and therefore could not be cosplayed by a Black person. It was so bizarre to me that someone who alleges themselves to be so devoted to the "authenticity" of the anime would consider a Black person cosplaying a non-Black character as "character rape", but failed to uphold the same standard when a white cosplayer would do the same. 

Jenkins piece focused on the gender differences within fandom/fanfic, yet failed to look at other important aspects such as class and race. Nerd culture, like Dungeons & Dragons dice, has many sides to it, with certain sides being ascribed more value to others. Black and brown nerds have been devalued in ways that are so illogical and bizarre that I cannot believe I still see it to this day.  I come-of-age surrounded by nerd culture; one that alleged itself to be an community where the ostracized could find solace. Where all "others" could be accepted, but even in a freeing environment such as Cons, the reality of the outside world seeps in like a poison gas. Nerds are not passive consumers but active participants in white supremacy and anti-Blackness. Thankfully Black and brown nerds are able to use online platforms such as blogs, social media, and even through podcasting to vocalize the racism we experience within our own chosen communities. I apologize if my thoughts are all over the place, but the readings reminded me of something that was so integral to my coming-of-age as well as the fact that community building is important and one of the great facets of fandoms.

Supplemental Post 1 - TV & Audiences- Gina Gonsalves

 After reading Watching Television Without Pity, I found it really interesting and honestly relatable in some  ways. I've never been a board-poster for any show but I do watch some shows religiously and often come across boards like these and spend time reading them and comparing my own opinions. For example, I am a huge Grey's Anatomy fan, once I started picking up production knowledge, I started analyzing the show deeply; by plot, character development, camera shots, lighting, and acting. I have come to do this with every show I get deeply invested in and often times I will read boards I come across to see what others thought, if anyone had similar options to me and sometimes just to judge if they were over-praising or over-criticizing parts of the show. 

I suppose I've always been aware of interactivity in television, at least in my generation as a millennial since it's only grown more and more since I've grown up, but I've never thought so deeply into the effect it may have on producers or even thought about the "free labor" portion; how by interacting on boards by providing criticism or praise, people are unaware they are voluntarily participating in an impromptu focus group. I agree that this is greatly impactful on television today, both as a way for viewers to see more of what they want and for producers and show runners to gauge audience interest by "free research" by feedback and interaction with their toughest critics, their viewers.

I did find it a little surprising that in the examples in the reading, such as The West Wing, the producers responded to online criticism with a degrading portrayal of internet users as obese, obsessed shut-ins. I could see that these online viewer critics could be ruthless in their criticisms, but I don't think that is a good way to handle it, in such a derogatory fashion; though it did address that these critics were heard. With the assumption these viewers have the best interest of a show and would like to give a viewer's input, I think it is important and necessary to hear from others perspectives, opinions, and criticisms for the sake of the show's direction and success with its viewers. 

Core Response #3 - Laura Broman

 

I wonder if Marc Andrejevic noticed a bit of the “savvy viewer” in himself, as someone implicitly claiming to be less duped than the people who say they aren’t duped, but actually are. And of course I’m being duped by pointing out how Andrejevic’s been duped, all of us claiming superiority through savvy over perceived lower levels of duped-ness like infinite levels of Plato’s cave.

I think Andrejevic makes an important point about the need to understand fan activity as distinct from fan activism, that “the binary opposition between complicit passivity and subversive participation needs to be revisited and revised” (43). He is not the first person I’ve seen question Jenkins’ somewhat utopian view of fandom, and with good reason, though I thought Jenkins’ piece was great and I’m very happy to have it in the world. To this argument about the exploitation of free labor in interactive fan spaces I will add the continued problem of toxicity in fan spaces, ranging from general entitlement (that remake-Season-8-of-Game-of-Thrones petition) to racism and misogyny (the abuse of Kelly Marie Tran).

However, I also think Andrejevic could be a bit more generous in his evaluation of the “TWoPpers” (ugh), which I find a bit deterministic. Andrejevic seems to view every statement of the TWoPpers, however different they are, as confirmation that they are fooling themselves despite every attempt to be above it all. While I definitely see shades of that toxic entitlement in some of the responses he shared, it is clear that many of them have a level of self-awareness about what they’re engaging in. Clearly many of his respondents have a sense of ambivalence about TWoP and the television they watch and are finding value where they can. In Hall’s terms I suppose we would call their readings negotiated while Andrejevic seems to prefer that they be fully oppositional. Is that how he goes about his life? It must be exhausting.

On a slightly different note, I wonder how we might apply a Bourdieu-type frame to the TWoPpers’ responses. Andrejevic argues that the practice of noting continuity errors or examining behind-the-scenes content points not towards “[imagining] how things might be done differently” but towards “[taking] pleasure in identifying with the insiders” (40). Is it worth applying the different forms of capital to this naive viewer/savvy viewer/producer hierarchy? I also wonder how the relationship of fandom to the forms of capital might have shifted in the past couple decades as certain types of geek content have grown increasingly mainstream. Have certain fans acquired a level of symbolic capital that wasn’t there at the time Newsweek came out with that trash story about Trekkies?

Core Response 1 - Kimberly

Something that stuck out to me in Andrejevic's piece, "Watching Television Without Pity," was the common practice of posting and reading TWoP at work. For me, it picks up a loose thread from the Morse reading. Discussing the ever more constructed nature of temporality in post-industrial life, Morse writes, "As Labor is more and more liberated from solar and circadian rhythms, cycles of commuting, shopping, and viewing become shiftable as well. Television schedules are 'intricately woven into the fabric of out daily activities' because they are organized by the same division of labor outside and inside the family which recruits the daily commuter and the recreational shopper" (202). (Although I will admit I am kind of guessing here) As the arbitrary rhythms of labor structure our experience of time, so too does leisure, and not the strolling-down-by-the-marsh-to-take-in-the-fresh-air variety of leisure (an image I copped from my current leisure activity, Grantchester on Masterpiece Mystery), but a constructed, produced, programmed variety. 

With the advent of interactive media, the structuring effect of TV can be warped by those who engage it. Andrejevic mentions multiple times the excess enjoyment viewers experience by posting to and reading TWoP, generally in terms of increased enjoyment, but an unmentioned effect that I suspect is also at play (taking from my personal experience) is extended enjoyment. By engaging with a community of fans, producing and consuming content as extensions of the television programming, viewers can continue to experience the pleasure of the finite product that had aired and ended on their television screens through a secondary interface.

Although the interpenetration of  labor and leisure time cuts both ways (lol) by allowing workers and employers to steal time from each other, the idea of TV warping temporality still excites me. It may not be radical or revolutionary, but extending the pleasure of the televisual experience raises questions for me of what qualifies as "watching TV." I'm not a sports person, but doesn't "game day" imply the tailgate just as much tossing the old... pig skin? Or something. 

These are, of course, the revelations of 2008. Sure, message boards could extend televisual pleasure into the work space, but now I watch TV shows, listen to podcasts about those shows while I walk around my neighborhood, scroll through memes about those shows scattered randomly (No! Algorithmically!) throughout my world news and celebrity gossip. The division that Andrejevic observes, that "the TV screen has been split into one to be watched and one to be interacted with" has been reconciled by new technology that makes those two screens one again. Not just those two screens, but the screen on which I bank, and ignore texts, and find romance, and play "Dots" (circa 2014).

Anyways, since this post inevitably ended up at the "Can you believe iPhones???" place, I'll share my surprise at learning that the lowercase i stood for interactive. I think there may be no better example of the development of time, meaning, and technology than this, because I remember the advent of the iPhone. I remember my first iPod shuffle. But I never knew that the i was the result of what I'm now sure was an extended marketing campaign to set the tone for a new era of tech consumerism. The signifier quickly became its own referent, the i in iPhone does not stand for anything, it simple is.

 

Supplemental Post 2 - Lilla


As I was reading the Jenkins article, I made the jarring realization that I, too, judge fandoms. Especially ones that I am part of. I think the sentiment stems from exclusivity and group thinking that in the past have made fandoms seem intimidating, exclusive and elitist to me — everything the Newsweek article Jenkins cites describes them as. When talking about fan fiction, Jenkins describes fans as “loyalists,” insistent on “rescuing essential elements of the primary text” (473). This reminded me of an experience I have had with a fandom I am a part of. I am a huge, huge fan of the 2006 UK teen drama series Skins. I have seen the show countless times in the past ten years and could probably quote the entire first two seasons back to back. Skins divided the show into so-called ‘generations,’ where they replaced the entire cast with new characters every two seasons. There were a total of six seasons and three generations (there was also a seventh season, featuring standalone episodes and returning characters, but for the purpose of this post, that doesn’t count). Of course, with three generations, there emerged a group of Skins ‘purists,’ who claimed that you’re only a true fan of the show if you acknowledge that the first generation is superior to the rest. Some of them have even refused to watch latter seasons out of principle, and have bullied actors from later generations on social media. They even turned against the creators of the show, arguing that they compromised quality and ‘Americanized’ it for global audiences, and increased the stakes to the extent that the shows core tenet of relatability was no longer recognizable.


It is fairly common for TV shows to decrease in quality in latter season (and I also happen to agree that the first two seasons of the show are the best) but I found the animosity purists have towards fans of the latter seasons is incredibly alienating. Of course, this show is by no means unique to this phenomenon — there are technology purists, Star Wars purists, purists for pretty much anything. But it was the first experience I had where I felt alienated from a fandom that I was part of because they created a hierarchy where not everybody is welcome. If fandoms are supposed to be places for “marginalized subcultural groups” (472), why does there have to be further marginalization? Why are you ‘not a real fan’ if you like a different season better, of if you can’t quote all the episodes back to back, or don’t have the theme song of the show as your ring tone (which I did in high school)? And who creates these arbitrary rules? Why do people in fandoms have to compete to one-up each other? To me, fandoms have become more of an alienating space than a welcoming community.

Supplemental Post 1 - Rojeen

During Andrejevic’s reading, I thought about the concept of audience interactivity and how “activity and interactivity need to be clearly distinguished from activism,” (43). Andrejevic didn’t just discuss the exploitative aspect of the audiences’ unpaid labor but reflected how their interactivity contributed to the social and material relations sustained in/through corporate power. It made me reflect on how little corporate networks care about implementing progressive politics and representations into their shows. For example, one of my professor’s had told me how they had been invited to be a consultant on a Netflix show, specifically because she works on representations of Middle Eastern characters and Muslims in the media. However, they had asked for her to come in after the show had already been produced. She had told me that the nature of the meeting was not to ensure the show resisted stereotypical representations of Middle Eastern/Muslim characters, but to ensure the network that their viewership wouldn’t be impacted because of the character’s representation. Not surprisingly, after the show was released, Muslims voiced on Twitter/YouTube/reddit how they felt the show spread misinformation about Islam and contributed to Orientalist tropes. Where activism and progressive politics are readily available, corporations like Netflix only engage in the name of profit.  


Supplemental Post 1 - Sabrina

 

This isn’t the first time I’ve read Jenkins and looked at fan studies for class, and every time it happens I feel somehow weirdly disconnected from the discussion. It feels like it should be something I’m interested in studying, as involvement in fandom isn’t insignificant in my life, but every time I just feel slightly uncomfortable.  Some of this probably stems from my involvement in fandom being similar but different from the practices discussed – reading fanfiction online and scrolling through Tumblr only sharing things with my immediate friends is different from the more active community involvement in conventions or creating content. I also think there’s a large part of me that sees academia as a professional sphere of interest, and fandom as where I go to relax/recreate/generally turn off my brain. In the theme of so many of the class readings about the blurring of leisure and work, or free time and discussion time, it makes sense to look at these readings through these angles, and there’s definitely value I can get from them. And so much of cinema and media studies is just taking recreational things and studying them seriously, so I’m still not fully sure why this disconnect is so strong, but I thought I’d at least attempt to reflect on the reasons.

Supplemental 4- Sabina

 Television and The Globe - What happens when a show goes international? Not to continue on this whole Drag Race trend, but I mean it is int...